|
|
Joni Haller
Whitewash
and Blacklist: The Effect of International Style
Politics on Julius Shulman's Career
At the height of Julius Shulman's career Elizabeth
Gordon, editor of the popular magazine House
Beautiful, would not publish his photographs
nor hire him for new assignments. She told Shulman
his photographs were "too cold" for American taste.
This reaction to Shulman's work was certainly
anomalous, for at this time he was in great demand,
accepting numerous assignments from both trade
journals and popular magazines including House
Beautiful's direct competitor, House &
Garden.
Gordon's dislike of
Shulman's work was, in fact, an aversion to the
type of architecture for which he was known to
photograph, namely, Modern architecture based on
the International Style. In a 1953 article titled
"The Threat to the Next America" Gordon revealed a
curious socio-political source of her distaste for
this architectural type. She claimed that
practitioners of the International Style aimed to
persuade the public to accept a decreased quality
of life--void of possessions and comfort--that
would ultimately leave them vulnerable to
dictatorial control.
Although Gordon's
slippery-slope argument seems comical today, it
indicates the extent to which cold-war hysteria
permeated popular consciousness during the postwar
period. Her argument also signifies, although in an
extreme manner, the general apprehension with which
Modern domestic dwellings were regarded and the
challenge Shulman faced in presenting them as
desirable, livable spaces. This essay examines the
importance of photography in shaping the perception
of the International Style, how this architecture
became entangled in various political agendas, and
the significant role these factors played
throughout Shulman's career.
|