BIS CD -1160.
The Chopin pieces are Ballades, Andante spianato & Grande
Polonaise, Polonaise-fantaisie & Fantaisie-impromptu.
This disc received two reviews recently. Jessica Duchen
compare the playing of this "lionised youth with another,
Evgeny Kissin" in the October 2001 issue of BBC Music Magazine.
She definitely preferred the latter and ended up giving
Freddy Kempf only a 2-star rating for performance.
Meanwhile Stephen Plaistow (Gramophone, Nov 2001) gives a
more scathing review. He chides the 24-year old for being "a
jumble of effects without causes...He is simply too
fast...rather flashy...much temperament and superficial
excitement, but unlikely to satisfy over the longer term."

SZYMANOWSKI AND RUBINSTEIN
If you are looking for Artur Rubinstein's rendition of his
friend Karol Szymanowski's "Symphonie Concertante" you will
find it in Vol. 32 of the Rubinstein Collection. The pianist
performed it with the L.A. Philharmonic undeer Alfred
Wallenstein.

BARGAIN CDs
Daedalus Music (800-395-2665 or www.salemusic.com) has three
outstanding discs at the reduced price of $5.98:
-
Catalog #17040. Adam Makowicz Trio: My Favorite Things - The
Music of Richard Rodgers. Adam Makowicz, piano. George Mraz,
bass. Alan Dawson, drums. Concord Jazz CD. Here the Polish
jazz pianist displays his usual "splendid technical prowess
and artistic finesse." According to the Wall Street Journal
"this gifted improviser" is "more than deserving of the
accolades he has received."
-
Catalog #09117. Chopin Piano Sonatas 2 & 3, Fantasie, Op. 49.
Shura Cherkassky, p. Ermitage/Decca.
-
Catalog #16617. Górecki: Three Pieces in Old Style; Good
Night & Kleines Requiem. I Fiamminghi, The Orchestra of
Flanders, Rudolf Werthen, cond. Telarc. The Requiem is now
one of Górecki's most frequently recorded music. A
Gramophone critic described it as "certainly one of his most
intriguiing and compelling pieces." The "Good Night"
memorial to the late Michael Vyner is an intensely beautiful
and moving piece - well worth getting the CD for this alone,
however, the "Requiem for a Polka" is still one of my
favorites.

ETHEL BARGAINS
Three other "bargain" discs are available from Ethel Enterprises
(800-648-2042):
-
#556692 NXS. "The Best of Lutosławski." Symphonic
Variations; Overture for Strings; Little Suite; Piosenka;
Concerto for Orchestra; Funeral Music; Epilogue; Jeux
Venitiens; Cello Concerto; Chain II; Piano Concerto. Various
artists, conductors & orchestras. Naxos. Only $6.79.
-
#74290 EMI. Chopin: Etudes, Op. 10 & Op. 25; Ballades 1-4;
Waltzes 1-19. Agustin Anievas, piano. Part of EMI Classics
doublefforte. Digitally remastered at Abbey Road Studios.
$15.59 (2 discs for the price of one).
-
#74302. Penderecki. Orchestral Works. Anaklasis for
strings & percussion; Threnody; Fonogrammi; De natura sonoris
Nos. 1 & 2; Capriccio for violin & orchestra; Canticum
canticorum salomonis; The Dream of Jacob; Emanationen for 2
string orchestras; Partita for harpsichord & orchestra;
Cello Concerto; Symphony. Wanda Wilkomirska, violin; Felicja
Blumenthal, harpsichord; Siegfried Palm, cello; Krzysztof
Penderecki, conducting. Polish Radio National Symphony Orchestra, London Symphony Orchestra. Emi Classics
doublefforte. $15.59 (2 for the price of 1).
LETTER TO THE EDITOR:by Joseph A. Herter
In spite of all the celebrations marking the 100th anniversary of the Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra, there has been one egregious omission in the Philharmonic's jubilee events. While choosing to program the music of Ignacy Paderewski, the orchestra's administration has completely neglected the works of the other great Polish composers who, 100 years ago, were found worthy to be performed on the Warsaw Philharmonic's first concert of November 5, 1901. True, Zygmunt Noskowski's Step and Stanislaus Moniuszko's 'Bajka' Overture will be heard during the season, but only as part of the repertoire of visiting amateur or professional orchestras. Sadly, however, the music of Wladyslaw Zelenski (1837-1921) and of his most outstanding student, Zygmunt Stojowski (1870-1946), is being completely ignored by any ensemble performing at the National Philharmonic Hall this centennial season.
Partially because of time constraints and partially because of current musical tastes, one can understand the National Philharmonic's decision not to replicate that historic concert of 1901. However, the Philharmonic's additional decision to completely ignore at least two of the country's historically important musical sons, rather than fulfilling an obligation to salute those famous Polish composers of a century past, will only serve to further reinforce the situation whereby the musical public sees the names of Zelenski and Stojowski, if it ever sees them at all, as curiosities of the fin-de-siecle rather than being amongst the most famous representatives of Polish music. By continuing to avoid playing the music of these two composers in our concert halls and on commercial Polish recordings, people in decision-making positions-such as those at the Warsaw Philharmonic-are depriving Polish society of the right to know its musical heritage and are denying them access to it in both the concert hall and at home. To be blunt, thanks to the Warsaw Philharmonic's planning of its centennial year, Polish society is being cheated of an important part of its heritage.
Stojowski, in particular, played an important role as the first Polish symphonist of any high caliber. His orchestral music was heard and played by the finest orchestras in Berlin, Hamburg, Leipzig, London, Paris and St. Petersburg in the 1890's when the composer was only in his twenties! Peter Tchaikovsky was scheduled to conduct Stojowski's Suite in E-flat in 1894, and in 1895, by command of Her Majesty Queen Victoria, Stojowski's cantata Spring was premiered at a State Concert that was held at Buckingham Palace. For a good twenty years Stojowski's position as one of Poland's most outstanding composers was unquestioned. When he immigrated to the USA in 1905, Stojowski was hailed as a great composer, pianist and pedagogue, and he had the distinction of being the first Polish composer to have a concert entirely comprised of his music performed by the New York Philharmonic.
The decline in Stojowski's popularity was due to his being a diehard romantic who appeared in the musical world on the brink of a revolution that dramatically changed musical styles, tastes and compositional techniques. Stojowski refused to change. In fact, he basically stopped composing around World War I and directed his energy into performance and teaching.
For our musical heritage to be properly cherished it must first of all be heard. I think it behooves Warsaw's National Philharmonic Orchestra to reconsider the programming for its centennial year and to add some orchestral works by Stojowski and his teacher Zelenski to the remaining programs of the season.
Sincerely yours, Joseph A. Herter, Warszawa
COMMEMORATONS & ANNIVERSARIES: